It is highly recommended that advisors and students actually read the degree description at some stage! Note that the Oral Comprehensive is absolutely not intended to be a seminar followed by polite questions for a few minutes. It is the only opportunity for the dissertation advisor to assess the advisee's depth of knowledge in the specialties which will be needed for the dissertation. In the degree description it is plainly written that:
That is, a plan of study should be agreed on in advance between the advisor and the student, and a copy filed with the Graduate Coordinator. Typically this would be a list of specific advanced texts, articles, and courses to be mastered, and it can be sent in by e-mail
At the time of the exam, the student may choose to make a presentation of some material, but this should not exceed twenty minutes, unless it is the student's original research. The presentation in no way replaces or constrains the questions, which should constitute the greater part of the event. Afterwards, the Oral Committee reports the result of the exam to the Graduate Coordinator.
Some regulations. Every doctoral student in Mathematics shall pass this exam within 3 years since first enrolling in the doctoral program. [Students in the doctoral program as of May 2006, may elect to follow the old rule requiring them to pass this exam within 18 months of completion of the written portion of the Comprehensive Exams.] The Oral Exam Committee consists of the dissertation advisor and two or more members chosen by student and his or her advisor. An additional member is appointed by the Graduate Coordinator or the Graduate Committee.
Permissions are not needed from the Vice Provost's office. It is common but not necessary for Oral Committee members later to become members of the Dissertation Committee.
When taking this exam, the form must be completed by the Advisor and returned to the Graduate Coordinator.
The student takes responsibility for announcements, room reservations, delivering copies of the dissertation, etc. The student and/or his/her advisor, must make a copy of the theisis available to all members of the Dissertation Committee at least two weeks before the defense date, or as otherwise agreed with the Committee's members.
The final public oral is a public event, and after a presentation of the dissertation the public is invited to ask questions of the candidate. The public is then dismissed and the Committee continues to ask probing questions. Eventually the candidate leaves the room and the Committee deliberates, then announces the decision. The Committee reports the result of the defense to the Graduate Coordinator and to the Vice Provost. The dissertation is archived electronically.
When taking this exam, the form must be completed by the Advisor and returned to the Graduate Coordinator.
When taking this exam, the form must be completed by the Advisor and returned to the Graduate Coordinator.